Visitor-to-member conversion was underperforming relative to the audience Mystic had.
The museum welcomed hundreds of thousands of visitors each year. Family attendance was strong, anchored by the LEGO exhibition and a robust seasonal program. But conversion from first-time visitor to paying member was inconsistent, strong in peaks, weak in between, and with no system to close the gap.
The problem was not effort. It was architecture. Every campaign started over. Together built something that wouldn’t.
A structured membership program built to run, repeat, and grow.
Audience Segmentation Framework: visitors categorized by type, engagement level, and membership likelihood, giving the team a foundation for targeted communication.
Multi-Touch Email Conversion Sequence: a structured journey from first visit to membership, with messaging tailored to where each audience segment was in the decision process.
Onsite Conversion Strategy: a visitor journey audit and conversion point recommendations, aligned with how families actually moved through the museum.
Automation Infrastructure: email sequences and trigger workflows built into the museum’s existing platform, designed to run with minimal ongoing management.
Performance Measurement Framework: defined KPIs, tracking setup, and a reporting cadence that gave the team clear visibility into what was working.
A system the organization owns, uses, and builds on.
Within the first ten weeks on the new platform, the system was already running ahead of plan. New family memberships paced at 167% of the annual goal, well ahead of where the calendar said they should be. Auto-renewal enrollments, starting from zero, nearly doubled in a single month, turning one-time joins into a recurring base that compounds instead of resetting each year.
Email grew into a revenue channel of its own, up 34% month over month. And when paid media launched, it returned more than ten times its cost in the first two weeks. The new microsite changed the quality of every visit, too: average engagement time more than doubled to over two minutes, with visitors moving through roughly five pages per session. The infrastructure is now the museum’s to run, and it is built to keep improving.
[ Name ], [ Title ]
How long does a program like this take?
It depends on scope, but most engagements run as a focused sprint. The core system, including the audience framework, email sequences, and automation, is typically built and live within the first few months, with performance compounding from there. The exact timeline is mapped at the outset in discovery, so you know what to expect before the work begins.